Podcast Ep #103 Why ‘All or Nothing’ Thinking Is Sabotaging Your Wellness

Scroll down to find all the ways to enjoy this content: blog post + video + podcast!
You can READ or WATCH or LISTEN!

Click to hop to the one you want:

✨ Why ‘All or Nothing’ Is Sabotaging Your Wellness ✨

Have you ever missed a day of something you committed to doing daily —maybe a workout, meditation, or journaling—and immediately felt like a complete failure?

Like you had to start over, maybe on Monday, the start of the month or maybe January 1?

If so, you’re not alone. I’ve been life coaching women in midlife for over 30 years and I hear it again and again (and have done it myself!).

We often fall into what I call the all-or-nothing trap, and it’s one of the biggest hidden obstacles to creating lasting wellness, energy, and balance.

For decades, we’ve been conditioned to believe that if we can’t do something perfectly, it’s not worth doing at all. Whether it’s our careers, family responsibilities, or our own health, perfectionism becomes a default. We give, we perform, we achieve—but when it comes to ourselves, even a small slip feels catastrophic.

The truth? Missing a day—or even a few days—doesn’t mean you’ve failed. In fact, small, consistent steps are far more powerful than perfect every day. Let’s unpack why this mindset is sabotaging your wellness and how to break free.

Resources for you:

NEW RELEASE: Waitlist: https://wellness.myflodesk.com/waitlist

THIS Is What’s Holding You Back From Manifesting

Manifestation Isn’t Just Mental — It’s Physical (Exhausted bodies don’t manifest)

➡️ SUBSCRIBE to the YouTube channel for FREE

➡️ (Peri)Menopause playlist to check out

PRIVATE LIFE COACHING:

Private Coaching when you are ready for the ultimate, exclusive experience: Life Coaching with Laura

READ: 

Why Midlife Women Default to All-or-Nothing

Many women in midlife are high achievers, caregivers, and problem solvers. We’ve been taught to “do it right,” to push through, to always prioritize others before ourselves. This conditioning creates a mindset where anything less than perfection feels unsafe.

If you’re a high achiever, you likely feel like:

• Missing a workout means you’ve undone all your progress
• Skipping a meditation means you’re failing spiritually or emotionally
• Eating one “off-plan” meal means you’re back at square one

This all-or-nothing thinking is not a personal flaw—it’s a nervous system response. Under pressure, your body defaults to survival mode, which can look like freezing, avoidance, or self-criticism. The result? Shame, guilt, and eventually, quitting altogether.

Why “Everyday Thinking” Backfires

When we tell ourselves we have to do wellness perfectly every day, the pressure can feel crushing. Miss a single day, and suddenly your nervous system interprets it as failure. That shame spike kills momentum and makes it harder to return the next day.

This is exactly why many women give up. They don’t fail because the practices don’t work—they fail because the all-or-nothing mindset creates a cycle of shame and avoidance.

The 80/20 Rule: How to Break Free

Here’s the good news: you can reshape your wellness practice without guilt or punishment. One of my favorite strategies is the 80/20 Rule (or 4/5 Rhythm).

1. Plan to do it every day – mentally commit to consistency
2. Decide how many days would really make a difference for you 
3. Celebrate consistency, not perfection – even small wins count
4. Track it – so you can see that you’re showing up more than you think

By focusing on progress instead of perfection, you build momentum and reinforce your nervous system that wellness is safe, achievable, and rewarding.

You Aren’t Starting Over

Here’s a mindset shift that changes everything: missing a day doesn’t mean starting over. Instead, think: “I am a woman who returns.”

Compare the two:

• Old mindset: “I missed a day; I’ll never get this right; I’m always starting over.”
• New mindset: “I missed a day; I’m continuing. I am a woman who returns.”

That tiny shift in language and identity is incredibly powerful. It turns wellness from something stressful into something freeing. It makes SIMPLY well feel like relief, not another thing to fail at.

Small Wins Are Powerful

When you stop punishing yourself for imperfection, something magical happens. Small, consistent wins in wellness compound into real results. You’ll start to notice the shift in how you are feeling, including a sense of accomplishment without stress.

The key is to dismantle the all-or-nothing mindset first. Only then can small, achievable habits feel like progress instead of another potential failure.

Think of it this way: one gentle yoga session, five minutes of journaling, or drinking an antioxidant-rich smoothie may feel “small,” but done consistently, it adds up to big transformation over time.

How to Start Today

1. Acknowledge the trap – notice when you think in all-or-nothing terms

2. Use the 80/20 Rule – commit to consistency, not perfection

3. Celebrate every return – missing a day isn’t failing

4. Track your wins – even small victories matter

5. Shift your identity – “I am a woman who returns”

When you practice these steps, wellness stops feeling like punishment and starts feeling like relief, choice, and empowerment.

Your Next Step

If you’re ready to break free from all-or-nothing thinking, start by choosing one habit this week and committing to doing it 4–5 days. Track it, celebrate it, and remind yourself: you aren’t starting over—you’re continuing.

In the next video of this series, we’ll explore why small is powerful when you stop punishing yourself—and how to make SIMPLY :: well (the release that is coming…) feel effortless and achievable.

Remember: Wellness doesn’t have to feel impossible. You don’t need perfect every day. You just need to return, consistently, with compassion. That’s where transformation happens—and that’s where relief lives.

Try a Home Retreat with me!

serenity at home: Home Design Kit
Theme: Letting Go 

If you want to plan your first retreat day with ease, I created a Home Retreat Kit to make it simple, structured, and fun.

Think gentle guidance, not rigid rules.

Think nourishment, not obligation.

Think “exhale,” not “effort.”

Because you deserve restoration—real restoration.

You don’t need to push harder.

You need to come home to yourself.

One day at a time.

One breath at a time.

One retreat at a time.

Want More Support?

hacking happiness:

Hacking happiness is my Life Coaching Quick Start course. Receive the first few steps for enjoying your life more. Learn more here.

Not ready to invest in yourself?

Totally understand! Grab this FREE ebook and watch for follow up emails and I’ll help you get started!

WATCH: 

LISTEN: 

Or link here to listen & find links to everywhere you listen to podcasts.

Leave me a voicemail and I can answer it on the podcast: Voicemail.